This site uses cookies. Visit our cookies policy page or click the link in any footer for more information and to change your preferences.

Accept all cookies Accept only essential cookies
Skip to main content
European Banking Authority logo
  • Extranet
  • Log in
  • About us
    Back

    About us

    The EBA is an independent EU Authority.  We play a key role in safeguarding the integrity and robustness of the EU banking sector to support financial stability in the EU.

    Learn more
      • Mission, values and tasks
      • Organisation and governance
        • Governance structure and decision making
        • EBA within the EU institutional framework
        • Internal organisation
        • Accountability
      • Legal and policy framework
        • EBA regulation and institutional framework
        • Compliance with EBA regulatory products
      • Sustainable EBA
      • Diversity and inclusion
      • Careers
        • Vacancies
        • Meet our team
      • Budget
      • Procurement
    Close menu panel
  • Activities
    Back

    Activities

    To contribute to the stability and effectiveness of the European financial system, the EBA develops harmonised rules for financial institutions, promotes convergence of supervisory practices, monitors, and advises on the impact of financial innovation and the transition to sustainable finance.

    Start here
      • Single Rulebook
      • Implementing Basel III in Europe
      • Supervisory convergence
        • Supervisory convergence
        • Supervisory disclosure
        • Peer Reviews
        • Mediation
        • Breach of Union Law
        • Colleges
        • Training
      • Direct supervision and oversight
        • Markets in Crypto-assets
        • Digital operational resilience Act
      • Information for consumers
        • National competent authorities for consumer protection
        • How to complain
        • Personal finance at the EU level
        • Warnings
        • Financial education
        • National registers and national authorities responsible for handling complaints related to credit servicers
        • Frauds and scams
      • Research Workshops
      • Ad hoc activities
        • Our response to Covid-19
        • Brexit
    Close menu panel
  • Risk and data analysis
    Back

    Risk and data analysis

    To ensure the orderly functioning and stability of the financial system in the European Union, we monitor and analyse risks and vulnerabilities relevant for the regulation of banks and investment firms. We also facilitate information sharing among authorities and institutions through supervisory reporting and data disclosure.

    Learn more
      • Risk analysis
        • 2024 EU wide transparency exercise
        • EU-wide stress testing
        • Risk monitoring
        • Thematic analysis
      • Remuneration and diversity analysis
      • Reporting frameworks
        • Reporting Time Traveller
        • DPM data dictionary
      • Data
        • Registers and other list of institutions
        • Guides on data
        • Aggregate statistical data
        • Secondary reporting: data from Competent Authorities to the EBA
        • Data analytics tools
    Close menu panel
  • Publications and media
    Back

    Publications and media

    Communicating to all our audiences in the most effective way and using the most appropriate channels is crucial for us. Through our publications, announcements, and participation in external events, we are committed to reaching out to all our stakeholders to report about our policies, activities, and initiatives.

    Learn more
      • Publications
        • Guidelines
        • Regulatory Technical Standards
        • Implementing Technical Standards
        • Reports
        • Consultation papers
        • Opinions
        • Decisions
        • Staff papers
        • Annual reports
      • Press releases
      • Speeches
      • Interviews
      • Events
      • Media centre
        • Media gallery
        • Media resources
    Close menu panel

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Single Rulebook Q&A
  3. 2024_7065 Provision of external payroll accounting services to an employer
Question ID
2024_7065
Legal act
Directive 2015/2366/EU (PSD2)
Topic
Authorisation and registration
Article
4
Paragraph
3
COM Delegated or Implementing Acts/RTS/ITS/GLs/Recommendations
Not applicable
Article/Paragraph
N/A
Name of institution / submitter
Czech National Bank
Country of incorporation / residence
Czech Republic
Type of submitter
Competent authority
Subject matter
Provision of external payroll accounting services to an employer
Question

Does the activity of external payroll processing for an employer constitute a payment service under PSD2, if it consists of receiving funds for wages and related deductions (taxes, health and social insurance) in the payroll processor’s payment account from the employer, and transferring these to employees, tax authorities, insurance companies etc.? Would the answer change depending on whether the payroll processor  maintains an account separately for each employer? 

 

Background on the question

The positive definition of payment services is set out in Annex 1 of PSD2. In general, if a third party intermediates a cashless transfer of funds between the payer and the payee, it is considered a payment service. Article 3 of PSD2 exempts certain types of intermediated transfers of funds from payment service regulation.

The activity of payroll processors, which consists of receiving funds from employers, i.e. into a payment account held by the payroll processor, and transferring these funds to the accounts of the respective employees as well as of the recipients of payroll deductions, has the characteristics of the provision of payment services, unless an exemption from the application of PSD2 applies. 

Due to the narrow scope of the above-mentioned activity, which clearly is not a general way of making payments generating risks that PSD2 is addressing, it seems that it should be exempted from PSD2 application. However, Article 3 of PSD2 does not contain any specific exemption for payroll processing.  The limited network or commercial agent exemptions do not seem to be applicable, as both exclude only payments related to the purchase or sale of goods or the provision or use of services. Neither wages nor deductions (tax, health and social insurance) can be considered payments for a service or a good. According to Directive 2006/123/EC on services in the internal market, “'service' means any self-employed economic activity, normally provided for remuneration, as referred to in Article 50 of the Treaty”. Recital  87 of this Directive further provides: "The main characteristic of an employment relationship within the meaning of Article 39 of the Treaty is that a person provides services to another person for a certain period of time on the latter's instructions and receives remuneration for those services. Any activity carried out by a person outside a relationship of subordination must be regarded as a self-employed activity within the meaning of Articles 43 and 49 of the Treaty". Wages cannot be considered payments for services provided by employees to their employer. As far as tax contributions and health and social insurance is concerned, there is no consideration being provided against these payments, these are legal obligations, not services being bought by employees from the state or insurance companies.

Even if the employment relationship could be considered a service, the commercial agent exemption under Article 3(b) PSD2 could apply, as a payroll processor is not authorised via an agreement to negotiate or conclude the sale or purchase of services in the second case, as they were not involved in negotiating the employment contract in any way.

Remaining exemptions do not seem to be applicable either. External payroll processing therefore seem to constitute a payment service requiring authorisation under PSD2. 

On the other hand, if the payroll processor is only given access to employer’s payment account, and initiates transfers from this account directly to accounts of employees, tax authorities etc., and never holds any employer’s funds himself (i.e. „without … entering at any time into possession of the funds to be transferred“ as per Art. 3(j) of PSD2), this does not constitute provision of payment services.

Submission date
23/04/2024
Status
Question under review
Answer prepared by
Answer prepared by the European Commission because it is a matter of interpretation of Union law.

Footer

EUROPEAN BANKING AUTHORITY

Our mission is to contribute to the stability and effectiveness of the European financial system through simple, consistent, transparent, fair regulation and supervision that benefits all EU citizens.


UE logoAn agency of the EU

EU Agencies Network logoEU Agencies Network

EMAS logoSustainable EBA

Contact us

  • Contacts
  • Ask a general question
  • Send a press query
  • Ask a regulatory question
  • File a complaint
  • Whistleblower reports

Stay up to date with our work

  • Subscribe to our email alerts
  • News & press RSS feed

Follow us on Social media

  • Bluesky
  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • YouTube

Find out about us

  • The EBA at a glance
  • Vacancies
  • Privacy policy
  • Legal notice
  • Cookies policy
  • Frauds and scams

Explore related sites

  • EIOPA
  • ESMA
  • ESRB
  • CEBS archive