EBA publishes its Opinion in response to the European Commission intention to amend the EBA Technical Standards for open and secure electronic payments under the PSD2

  • Press Release
  • 30 June 2017
The European Banking Authority (EBA) published today an Opinion responding to the European Commission's (EC) intention to amend the EBA's draft Regulatory Technical Standards (RTS) on strong customer authentication and common and secure communication. In its Opinion, while agreeing with the aims sought in the EC's amendments, the EBA voices its disagreement with three of the four concrete amendments the Commission proposes on the basis that it would negatively impact the fine trade-off and balances previously found in the RTS.
The EBA's draft RTS, published in February, sought to establish the legislative framework as mandated under PSD2 and to contribute to confidence and trust in the new payment services that PSD2 will bring about from 13 January 2018. In the process of developing the RTS, the EBA had to make difficult trade-offs between the various, at times competing, objectives of the PSD2, such as enhancing security, promoting customer convenience, ensuring technology and business-model neutrality, contributing to the integration of the European payment markets, protecting consumers, facilitating innovation, and enhancing competition through new payment initiation and account information services. 
In its letter dated 24 May 2017, the Commission expressed its intention to amend the EBA's draft RTS in four main areas. These included the proposal for the audits to be performed by statutory auditors; an additional, standalone exemption to be added for specific types of corporate transactions; for payment service providers to report the outcome of the monitoring and calculation of the fraud rate to the EBA; and, finally, to require Account Servicing Payment Service Providers (ASPSPs) that have set up a dedicated interface to ensure that Account Information Service Providers (AISPs) and Payment Initiation Service Providers (PISPs) can access the ASPSP's customer interface as a fall-back in case the dedicated interface is not performing as required under the RTS.
While the EBA agrees with the aims sought in the European Commission's amendments, the EBA disagrees with some of the means by which the Commission is proposing to achieve that aim. More specifically, the EBA disagrees with three of the four proposed amendments and is of the view that the suggested changes would negatively impact the fine trade-off previously found by the EBA in achieving the various competing objectives of the PSD2. With that in mind, the EBA is suggesting in its Opinion some alternative means through which the Commission's aims can be achieved. 

Next Steps

The publication and submission to the EU Commission of today's Opinion concludes the EBA's work on this regulatory mandate. It is now for the EU Commission to make the final decision on the text of the RTS and to adopt the standards as a delegated Act in the Official Journal of the EU. During the adoption process, the EU Council and EU Parliament have a scrutiny right. Once the RTS have been published in the Official Journal, they will enter into force the following day and will apply 18 months after that date.

Legal basis and background

The draft RTS have been developed according to Article 98 of the revised Payment Services Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2), which mandates the EBA, in close cooperation with the ECB, to draft Regulatory Technical Standards (RTS) specifying the requirements of the strong customer authentication (SCA), the exemptions from the application of SCA, the requirements with which security measures have to comply in order to protect the confidentiality and the integrity of the payment service users' personalised security credentials, and the requirements for common and secure open standards of communication (CSC) between account servicing payment service providers, payment initiation service providers, account information service providers, payers, payees and other payment service providers (PSPs).
The EBA published its final draft report in February 2017, following 18 months of intensive policy development work and consultation with the different payment market players.
With today's Opinion, the EBA exercise its competence under Article 10 of the EBA Founding Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010), which mandates the EBA to deliver an Opinion on the Commission's proposed amendments to the RTS as well as revised RTS within six weeks of receiving the EC's letter. 


RTS on SCA and CSC - Annex Table 28 - June 2017.pdf

(7.72 KB - PDF) Last update 29 June 2017

RTS on SCA and CSC - amended by EBA - June 2017.pdf

(430.07 KB - PDF) Last update 29 June 2017

EBA Opinion on the amended text of the RTS on SCA and CSC (EBA-Op-2017-09)

(398.04 KB - PDF) Last update 29 June 2017

(EBA-2017-E-1315) Letter from O Guersent, FISMA re Commission intention to amend the draft RTS on SCA and CSC -Ares(2017)2639906

(273.68 KB - PDF) Last update 26 June 2017

Press contacts

Franca Rosa Congiu