Joint Consultation on mechanistic references to credit ratings in the ESAs’ guidelines and recommendations

  • Consultation
  • 5 DECEMBER 2013
  • JC/CP/2013/02

The Joint Committee of the European Supervisory Authorities (EBA, ESMA and EIOPA - ESAs) is launching today a one-month public consultation on the removal of mechanistic references to credit ratings in their guidelines and on the definition of sole and mechanistic reliance on such ratings.

The term “sole and mechanistic reliance on credit ratings” is mentioned in Article 5b(1) of the European Regulation on Credit Rating Agencies (Regulation (EU) No 462/2013). However, neither its formal definition nor explanations of its meaning are included in the document.

In order to have a common approach towards this issue, the ESAs have developed a definition of “sole and mechanistic reliance”, and are consulting with market participants on whether this definition is clear and can be used in practice. The consultation paper contains:

  • a proposed definition for “sole or mechanistic reliance”, including examples;
  • the provisions in the three ESAs’ guidelines that are not to be defined as mechanistic; and
  • those provisions that are to be considered as mechanistic and therefore should be amended.

The ESAs intend to refer to this definition in all their future guidelines, recommendations and draft technical standards where relevant.

The current public consultation also contributes to the initiative of the Financial Stability Board to reduce the reliance on ratings.

The consultation paper is available on the websites of the three ESAs: EBA, ESMA and EIOPA.

The consultation will end on 5 December 2013 cob. Please note that comments submitted after the deadline will not be processed.


The form is now closed.


Consultation Paper

(349.97 KB - PDF) Last update 26 February 2014